Privacy policy
bonnot paris logo
Studio

A guide to choosing the right engagement ring

Bonnot Paris
April 29, 2026
-
5 min read
bague d'anniversaire saphir teal écrin bonnot


Bonnot Paris · The Precious Stone Journal 2026

Choosing the right ring: seven mistakes

It is not the wrong choices that prove costly, but decisions made in the wrong order — or too late. The seven we see most often.
By François Deprez, founder · Guide · 9 min · September 2026
In eight years, we have almost never seen anyone choose the wrong stone. We have seen hundreds of projects marred by a decision made in the wrong order.
In brief

For Bonnot Paris, a jeweller and dealer in coloured gemstones in Paris, choosing the right engagement ring means avoiding seven mistakes: starting with the design rather than the stone, thinking in carats rather than millimetres, choosing from a screen, forgetting the wedding band, getting the size wrong, neglecting the certificate and leaving it too late. The house method: first choose the stone, in person, then design the setting around it. Bonnot Paris welcomes clients by appointment at its Paris showroom or by video consultation, with a selection prepared in advance according to budget and date.

An engagement ring is not a complicated purchase. It becomes complicated when it is treated as an object to find rather than a project to manage — and the following seven mistakes recur with disconcerting regularity.

None is a matter of taste. They are errors of method, and all can be corrected free of charge, provided they are known in advance.

Oval blue sapphire ring with a diamond pavé halo, yellow gold — Bonnot Paris
2.23 ct oval blue sapphire, pavé halo — €10,920. The design came after the stone: that is the whole point of this article.
01

Starting with the design

This is by far the most common, and the most logical: you spot a ring online, fall in love with the design, then look for the gemstone that will fit it.

The problem is arithmetic. A design fixes dimensions; you then need to find a stone that matches this precise format, in this colour, within this budget — three simultaneous constraints. Nine times out of ten, one ends up accepting a gemstone chosen by default.

The reverse order costs less and delivers a better result: the stone is chosen from what actually exists, then the setting is designed around its dimensions. In this respect, a sapphire engagement ring offers the widest range — ten colours and the deepest stock in our catalogue, meaning fewer compromises.

What really matters twenty years on

Colour, not design. Settings go out of fashion, tastes evolve, and a setting can be reworked — the stone cannot. That is what must be chosen without compromise.

02

Thinking in carats

A carat measures weight, not size. Two stones of the same weight can differ by more than a millimetre in diameter depending on their cutting depth — and many are cut deep precisely to retain carat weight, and therefore sell for more at the same visible surface area.

Oval Mozambique ruby ring surrounded by diamonds, yellow gold — Bonnot Paris
Mozambique ruby surrounded by diamonds — €37,200. In this category, colour outweighs weight to the point of reversing the logic of pricing.

The case of red is the most striking, and it should be a lesson to everyone. Among our six rubies in stock, the price per carat falls as the weight rises : the smallest stone, a pure red 1.50 ct, costs €22,520/ct, while the largest, pinkish, falls to €5,800/ct. A ruby engagement ring should therefore be judged by its saturation, never by the figure on the certificate.

A practical consequence, valid across all categories: be wary of a large stone offered at a price that seems reasonable. Nine times out of ten, it is not a bargain — it is a more subdued colour, heavy treatment, or both.

03

Choosing on screen

A stone does not create light: it reflects what it is given. Warm light draws hues towards red, daylight towards blue. The same teal sapphire can appear distinctly blue in a display case and noticeably green by a window.

No screen is calibrated like yours, and a studio photograph is lit to flatter. The test that matters is elsewhere: look at the stone in daylight, then in the evening in a lit room. If the colour collapses when the light fades, the ring will not leave the drawer.

From a distance, the minimum acceptable option is a video on a neutral hand, under several types of lighting, without colour retouching. A seller who provides only retouched photographs is selling you an image, not a gemstone.

04

Forgetting the wedding band

This cannot be remedied afterwards. A wedding band sits against the engagement ring — and that single question changes three design parameters, which can no longer be altered once the ring has been made.

Oval Zambian emerald ring, floral yellow gold and diamond setting — Bonnot Paris
Zambian emerald in a floral setting — €11,040. With this type of design, the wedding band will need to be notched: this must be decided before production.

The three parameters are the setting height — a low-set stone will never allow a straight band to fit beneath it —, the band profile, and the shape of the gallery beneath the stone, which may protrude and prevent any contact.

With an emerald engagement ring, the issue goes beyond aesthetics. With a hardness of 7.5 to 8, the stone does not withstand repeated friction from metal against its edges well: we almost always design a notched wedding band, even when the geometry would allow a straight band.

The good news

There is no obligation to make the wedding band straight away. We are happy to design both together and keep the measurements in the workshop : a wedding band requested five years later will fit to the millimetre.

05

Getting the size wrong

The most reliable method is still to discreetly borrow a ring she wears on her left ring finger and have it measured. Two pitfalls account for most errors.

The wrong finger. A ring worn on the middle finger or right ring finger will not give the correct measurement: the difference often reaches one and a half sizes. For right-handed people, the right ring finger is often half a size to one size larger than the left.

The wrong time. A finger measured in the morning, after sport or in hot weather can vary by a full size. Measure at the end of the day, at a normal temperature.

When in doubt, go larger

The first resizing is complimentary on our creations. A ring that is slightly too large on the day of the proposal causes no problem; a ring that will not fit does. A plain band can be resized in a few minutes — a fully pavé-set band, much less easily.

06

Overlooking the certificate

An independent laboratory report, verifiable by its number, specifies the nature of the gemstone, its weight, dimensions, treatments undergone and often its origin. Without it, no price makes sense.

Radiant-cut blue sapphire ring, bezel-set and flanked by baguettes, yellow gold — Bonnot Paris
2.55 ct radiant blue sapphire — €10,920. Every stone we sell comes with its laboratory report.

The first line to read is the one concerning treatments, because it determines both value and care. Heating a corundum and oiling an emerald are traditional, stable and accepted. Lead-glass filling in a ruby, coloured resins in an emerald or surface diffusion: no; they dramatically reduce value and weaken the stone.

A useful clarification for inherited jewellery: discovering that a family stone is treated or synthetic does not mean you were deceived. Ruby has been synthesised industrially since the beginning of the 20thth century, and nobody concealed it at the time.

07

Leaving it too late

Allow six to eight weeks between the first appointment and delivery of the jewel: one to two weeks to choose the stone and finalise the design, then three to five working weeks for production once the stone has been received at the workshop.

You have left What is possible
More than 3 months Anything, including dedicated sourcing for a rare stone.
2 to 3 months A complete creation from stock, including a personalised design.
1 to 2 months A creation using a stock stone, with an existing setting.
Less than one month Available ring, or loose stone

The last line deserves a word, because it is the escape route nobody considers. Propose with the stone alone, in its case and with its certificate, then design the ring together: the commitment is there, as is the value, and it removes the main risk of a surprise ring — choosing the wrong design rather than the wrong stone.

If you are running late

Do not rush the design to meet the date. Nobody will remember the delay, everyone will remember the ring.

02

Budget: what each tier allows

Let us talk numbers, since it is the question nobody dares to ask first. The tiers below are those of our sapphire collection in September 2026. The stone accounts for the greater part; the setting ranges from 1 250 € for a simple design to 10 000 € and more for extensive pavé or calibrated-stone work.

Budget What it allows
From €2,500 A 0.7 to 1 ct stone in a beautiful colour, set in a simple 18-carat gold mounting.
€5,000 to €8,000 A 1 to 2 ct stone, with a strong colour, in a fully customised setting. The heart of our projects.
€8,000 to €15,000 A rarer or unheated stone, a diamond surround or a complex setting.
€15,000 and above Exceptional origin, treatment or quality — unheated padparadscha or royal blue from 2.5 ct upwards.

These tiers apply to sapphire. The other families do not start at the same point: emerald starts lower, at around 1 700 €, and ruby considerably higher, at around 8 000 €, because it is the rarest of the four major stones above two carats.

The trade-off we recommend

For a given budget, always prioritise colour over weight. A 1.5 ct unheated teal sapphire with a vibrant blue-green hue makes a far more beautiful ring than an ordinary 2 ct blue stone. This is the trade-off we propose nine times out of ten, and the one we are thanked for having insisted upon.

03

Millimetres, not carats

A carat is a weight, not a size. It is the most common misconception, and it is costly: you pay for a number that cannot be seen on the finger.

Four sapphires in different colours and shapes placed on a finger before setting — Bonnot Paris
Four stones placed on a finger, before any setting. This is how we have them assessed: on a hand, in daylight — never against a white studio background.

Two two-carat stones can differ by a millimetre and a half in diameter depending on their depth. Many gems are cut deep to retain weight: they weigh more for the same visible surface area. And corundum — sapphire and ruby — is denser than diamond: at equal carat weight, it appears smaller.

A few benchmarks measured from our own stock, rather than a theoretical chart:

Shape and weight Observed dimensions
Round ~1 ct 5.6 to 6.7 mm in diameter
Oval ~1.5 ct From 6.7 × 5.1 mm to 8.4 × 6.6 mm (47 stones)
Cushion ~2 ct From 6.6 × 5.6 mm to 8.1 × 6.5 mm
Oval ~2.5 ct From 8.2 × 6.7 mm to 9.8 × 7.6 mm

Ranges recorded from Bonnot Paris stock, updated in August 2026.

The question to ask

Before buying, ask for the dimensions in millimetres, not merely the carat weight — and a video of the stone on a hand. A seller who does not provide them is selling you a number, not a gemstone.

06

Read a certificate

For a stone intended for an engagement ring, we want to have an independent laboratory report before approving the project. The laboratory is chosen according to the value of the gemstone: a local report, ICA, IGI or Bellerophon for most stones, GRS above a few thousand euros, SSEF or Gübelin for exceptional stones.

Anonymised gemmological laboratory report, with reading guidelines — Bonnot Paris
An anonymised laboratory report. Five lines are enough to assess it: identification, weight and dimensions, treatment, origin, laboratory and a verifiable number.

Identification must clearly state corundum or natural sapphire. Any other wording should raise concern. Weight and dimensions : millimetres are more telling than carat weight. Treatment : “no indication of heating” for an unheated stone; any other process must be disclosed. Origin, stated only when the laboratory can reach a conclusion — “origin undetermined” is not a flaw in the stone. Finally, the laboratory and a verifiable number.

What a certificate does not say

It establishes neither the quality nor the value of the gemstone. A report confirms a nature, a weight and treatments — it does not replace your eye, nor a comparison between two stones placed side by side. It is a necessary condition, never a sufficient one.

08

Choosing well, your questions

The stone or the setting first?

The stone, always. The setting is designed around its actual dimensions, never the other way round. Starting with a design spotted online means having to look for a gemstone that fits it, and one ends up accepting a stone chosen by default.

Is carat weight the right reference point?

No, millimetres are. Two stones of the same weight can differ by more than one millimetre in diameter depending on the depth of their cut. And in certain families, colour outweighs weight to such an extent that the most expensive stone per carat is also the smallest.

Can you choose from a photo?

No. No screen is calibrated like yours, and no studio photograph captures the behaviour of a gemstone under different lighting. Ask for a video on a neutral hand, under several lights and without colour retouching.

When should you think about the wedding band?

From the very first appointment. The question affects the setting height, the band profile and the shape of the gallery — three parameters that can no longer be changed once the ring has been made.

How can you find out the size discreetly?

Borrow a ring worn on the left ring finger and have it measured. A ring worn on another finger will not give the correct size — the difference often reaches one and a half sizes. When in doubt, aim slightly larger: the first resizing is complimentary.

Is the certificate essential?

Yes, for any stone intended for a valuable piece of jewellery. It specifies the nature, weight, dimensions, treatments and often the origin. Without it, no price makes sense — and certain treatments radically alter both value and care requirements.

How far in advance?

Six to eight weeks between the first appointment and delivery of the jewellery. If the date is closer, a ring available from the collection or a loose stone presented in its case can keep to the schedule without compromising the project.

Where should you begin?

With the stone. It determines the budget, proportions and colour; the setting is then designed around its actual dimensions. Reversing the order forces the stone into a design that was not conceived for it — and costs more to correct.

What budget should you allow?

Our sapphire creations start at €2,500 for a 0.7 to 1 ct stone in a beautiful colour on a simple setting. The core of our projects falls between €5,000 and €8,000, allowing for a 1 to 2 ct stone and a fully bespoke setting. Emerald starts at around €1,700, ruby at around €8,000. Prices observed in September 2026.

Should you look at carats or millimetres?

Millimetres. A carat is a weight: two 2 ct stones can differ by one and a half millimetres in diameter depending on their depth, and as corundum is denser than diamond, it appears smaller at the same weight. What matters is the visible surface on the finger.

Which setting should you choose?

The solitaire leaves all the room for colour. Floral and halo settings visually enlarge the stone — this is the design we most often recommend for a teal sapphire engagement ring. Art Deco frames it and requires a step cut. A low bezel setting is the safest choice for a very active hand.

Seven mistakes, zero inevitability

Tell us your budget, the date, and two or three pieces you have spotted online: we will prepare a selection before your visit and make decisions in the right order.


Share this post

Bonnot Paris
Founder of Bonnot Paris
Back to the journal