

Contrary to popular belief, the white diamond is not always the most expensive gemstone. Certain Burmese rubies or Kashmir sapphires command prices well above it per carat. The value of a stone depends on a precise combination of criteria — colour, origin, rarity, treatments — which Maison Bonnot Paris guides you through in this article.
The price of a precious stone per carat can range from a few hundred to several million euros depending on quality. Below are the four great gemstones ranked by their peak value potential.
The untreated Burmese ruby in pigeon blood colour is consistently the most expensive stone per carat. Its absolute rarity and natural fluorescence make it the holy grail of collectors.
The white diamond is modest in price compared to its coloured counterparts. Pink, blue and red diamonds rank among the most expensive stones ever sold at the great auction houses.
An exceptional Kashmir sapphire can exceed 100,000 € per carat. Its singular velvety blue colour, impossible to replicate through any treatment, makes it one of the most sought-after stones in fine jewellery.
The untreated Colombian emerald in muzo green reaches the very heights among green gemstones. Its warm, luminous colour remains unrivalled in the mineral world.
These prices reflect market values for exceptional stones. A very fine engagement ring starts from 2,000 € for an emerald or a sapphire, and from 3,000 € for a ruby or a diamond. Exceptional quality is rare — beautiful quality is within reach.
The ruby is, carat for carat, the precious stone most likely to reach record-breaking prices. Its exceptional value rests on a unique combination of factors: absolute rarity, unrivalled colour and a history spanning millennia.
The world benchmark colour is "pigeon blood" — a vivid, slightly bluish red evoking the blood of a pigeon. This precise term, now certified by gemmological laboratories, designates rubies from Burma (Mogok) of flawless saturation and brilliance. Their natural fluorescence under sunlight intensifies their radiance further, creating an inner glow that no other stone can replicate.
Fine untreated rubies above 3 carats are so rare that they trade almost exclusively between private collectors and the great auction houses. In more accessible jewellery, a beautiful ruby of 0.80 to 1.50 carats already offers extraordinary colour and presence for a truly singular engagement ring.
The "Sunrise Ruby", an untreated Burmese ruby of 25.59 carats, was sold at Sotheby's in 2015 for more than 28 million euros — equivalent to over 1 million euros per carat. It remains one of the most expensive coloured stones ever sold at auction.
The white diamond remains the most popular precious stone for engagement rings, yet its price per carat is far from the highest among gemstones. A D-IF white diamond (colourless, inclusion-free) of 1 carat is valued between 8,000 and 15,000 € — whereas a ruby or Kashmir sapphire of the same weight can be worth ten to a hundred times more.
It is through its coloured varieties — known as "fancy diamonds" — that the diamond reclaims its place among the world's most precious gems. Pink diamonds, sourced principally from the Argyle mine (Australia, closed in 2020), have become exceptionally rare. Blue diamonds, whose colour owes to the presence of boron, rank among the most coveted stones in the world.
| Diamond type | Colour | Indicative price / carat | Rarity |
|---|---|---|---|
| White diamond | Colourless D–Z | 3,000 – 15,000 € | Available |
| Fancy yellow diamond | Intense yellow | 5,000 – 30,000 € | Uncommon |
| Fancy pink diamond | Pale to intense pink | 100,000 – 500,000 € | Extremely rare |
| Fancy blue diamond | Vivid to intense blue | 200,000 – 800,000 € | Exceptionally rare |
Among sapphires, origin is decisive in determining value. A fine-quality sapphire from Sri Lanka or Madagascar is valued between 3,000 and 20,000 € per carat. But a Kashmir sapphire — whose deposits were exhausted by the 1930s — can exceed 100,000 € per carat.
The Kashmir colour is described as a velvety blue, or a "sleeping blue": an intense saturation with a subtle, diffuse transparency that renders the stone luminous even in low light. This quality arises from specific micro-inclusions that scatter light in a wholly unique way — impossible to replicate through treatment or synthesis.
Large untreated Ceylon (Sri Lanka) sapphires also represent a sound long-term choice, with their highly sought-after cornflower blue hues prized by bespoke jewellery houses.
The emerald holds a singular place in the world of gemstones. While fine-quality emeralds are attainable from €2,000 to €8,000 for an engagement ring, large untreated Colombian emeralds move into an entirely different scale of value.
The benchmark colour — "muzo green", named after the Colombian Muzo mine — is a warm, slightly bluish green with an inner luminosity that no treated emerald can match. A certificate confirming the complete absence of treatment (no oil) can multiply the value of an emerald by three to five times compared with a treated stone of the same colour.
Houses such as Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels and Bulgari have built iconic pieces around the emerald. Cartier's Tutti Frutti collection, with its Indian emeralds, helped enshrine this stone in the history of world high jewellery. At Bonnot Paris, we select our emeralds directly in Jaipur, the global hub of the green gem trade.
Beyond the classic 4Cs, several factors specifically determine the market value of a coloured precious stone. Here they are, in order of importance.
Value factor no. 1
Burma for ruby, Kashmir for sapphire, Colombia for emerald: a certified origin can multiply the value of a stone by two to ten times.
Untreated = absolute premium
A certified untreated stone is consistently worth far more than a similar treated one. Heating for sapphire and ruby, oiling for emerald, are common practices but reduce value.
70% of value
The benchmark hue (pigeon blood, muzo green, cornflower blue) justifies the premium price. A slight deviation from the ideal colour can halve or even reduce the value threefold.
GRS · GIA · ALGT
A certificate from a leading laboratory confirms origin and treatments. Without a recognised certificate, a top-tier stone loses a large part of its market value and liquidity.
Exponential value
Value does not increase linearly with weight — it is exponential. A 5-carat ruby is not worth five times a 1-carat ruby: it can be worth twenty to fifty times more.
History & collections
Having belonged to a great collection or a prestigious jewellery house adds further value. Stones with a documented history consistently sell above estimate.
Exceptional-quality precious stones have historically weathered economic downturns with resilience. Unlike financial assets, a fine certified gemstone is tangible, portable and universally recognised. It represents a discreet store of value that some investors choose to incorporate into their estate.
Untreated Burmese rubies, Kashmir sapphires and untreated Colombian emeralds are the three categories that have performed most strongly over the past twenty years. Their growing scarcity — the historic deposits being exhausted or close to it — provides structural long-term support to their value.
At Bonnot Paris, we guide clients who wish to combine beauty with lasting value in the choice of their bespoke jewel. Our direct sourcing in India, Sri Lanka and Thailand allows us to identify stones of high potential well before they reach the European market.
For a purchase that combines pleasure with investment, favour a certified precious stone with a fine natural colour, ideally untreated or minimally treated, and with a documented origin. It is the combination of these criteria — not carat weight alone — that will determine the future value of your stone. Book an appointment for personalised guidance.
The ruby is regularly the most expensive precious stone per carat. An untreated Burmese ruby of exceptional "pigeon blood" colour can exceed one million euros per carat at auction. Certain extraordinary pink or blue diamonds reach similar records, but at an even more extreme degree of rarity.
The exceptional value of the ruby lies in its absolute rarity: large untreated "pigeon blood" rubies from Burma are among the rarest gemstones on earth. Its hardness (9 on the Mohs scale), its natural fluorescence and its millennia-long history make it the precious stone most coveted by the great jewellery houses.
Not necessarily. While the white diamond is the most popular engagement stone, Burmese rubies, Kashmir sapphires and untreated Colombian emeralds often surpass the white diamond in value per carat. That said, extraordinary pink or blue diamonds rank among the most expensive stones ever sold at auction.
The value of a precious stone rests on the combination of the 4Cs (colour, clarity, cut, carat), its certified geographic origin, and the absence or presence of treatments. Only a gemmological certificate issued by a recognised laboratory (GIA, GRS, ALGT) can attest to these characteristics. At Bonnot Paris, all our stones are certified — book an appointment to find out more.
Partagez ce post
Découvrez d'autres articles qui peuvent vous intéresser pour approfondir votre passion pour la joaillerie !
View all


Contrary to popular belief, the white diamond is not always the most expensive gemstone. Certain Burmese rubies or Kashmir sapphires command prices well above it per carat. The value of a stone depends on a precise combination of criteria — colour, origin, rarity, treatments — which Maison Bonnot Paris guides you through in this article.
The price of a precious stone per carat can range from a few hundred to several million euros depending on quality. Below are the four great gemstones ranked by their peak value potential.
The untreated Burmese ruby in pigeon blood colour is consistently the most expensive stone per carat. Its absolute rarity and natural fluorescence make it the holy grail of collectors.
The white diamond is modest in price compared to its coloured counterparts. Pink, blue and red diamonds rank among the most expensive stones ever sold at the great auction houses.
An exceptional Kashmir sapphire can exceed 100,000 € per carat. Its singular velvety blue colour, impossible to replicate through any treatment, makes it one of the most sought-after stones in fine jewellery.
The untreated Colombian emerald in muzo green reaches the very heights among green gemstones. Its warm, luminous colour remains unrivalled in the mineral world.
These prices reflect market values for exceptional stones. A very fine engagement ring starts from 2,000 € for an emerald or a sapphire, and from 3,000 € for a ruby or a diamond. Exceptional quality is rare — beautiful quality is within reach.
The ruby is, carat for carat, the precious stone most likely to reach record-breaking prices. Its exceptional value rests on a unique combination of factors: absolute rarity, unrivalled colour and a history spanning millennia.
The world benchmark colour is "pigeon blood" — a vivid, slightly bluish red evoking the blood of a pigeon. This precise term, now certified by gemmological laboratories, designates rubies from Burma (Mogok) of flawless saturation and brilliance. Their natural fluorescence under sunlight intensifies their radiance further, creating an inner glow that no other stone can replicate.
Fine untreated rubies above 3 carats are so rare that they trade almost exclusively between private collectors and the great auction houses. In more accessible jewellery, a beautiful ruby of 0.80 to 1.50 carats already offers extraordinary colour and presence for a truly singular engagement ring.
The "Sunrise Ruby", an untreated Burmese ruby of 25.59 carats, was sold at Sotheby's in 2015 for more than 28 million euros — equivalent to over 1 million euros per carat. It remains one of the most expensive coloured stones ever sold at auction.
The white diamond remains the most popular precious stone for engagement rings, yet its price per carat is far from the highest among gemstones. A D-IF white diamond (colourless, inclusion-free) of 1 carat is valued between 8,000 and 15,000 € — whereas a ruby or Kashmir sapphire of the same weight can be worth ten to a hundred times more.
It is through its coloured varieties — known as "fancy diamonds" — that the diamond reclaims its place among the world's most precious gems. Pink diamonds, sourced principally from the Argyle mine (Australia, closed in 2020), have become exceptionally rare. Blue diamonds, whose colour owes to the presence of boron, rank among the most coveted stones in the world.
| Diamond type | Colour | Indicative price / carat | Rarity |
|---|---|---|---|
| White diamond | Colourless D–Z | 3,000 – 15,000 € | Available |
| Fancy yellow diamond | Intense yellow | 5,000 – 30,000 € | Uncommon |
| Fancy pink diamond | Pale to intense pink | 100,000 – 500,000 € | Extremely rare |
| Fancy blue diamond | Vivid to intense blue | 200,000 – 800,000 € | Exceptionally rare |
Among sapphires, origin is decisive in determining value. A fine-quality sapphire from Sri Lanka or Madagascar is valued between 3,000 and 20,000 € per carat. But a Kashmir sapphire — whose deposits were exhausted by the 1930s — can exceed 100,000 € per carat.
The Kashmir colour is described as a velvety blue, or a "sleeping blue": an intense saturation with a subtle, diffuse transparency that renders the stone luminous even in low light. This quality arises from specific micro-inclusions that scatter light in a wholly unique way — impossible to replicate through treatment or synthesis.
Large untreated Ceylon (Sri Lanka) sapphires also represent a sound long-term choice, with their highly sought-after cornflower blue hues prized by bespoke jewellery houses.
The emerald holds a singular place in the world of gemstones. While fine-quality emeralds are attainable from €2,000 to €8,000 for an engagement ring, large untreated Colombian emeralds move into an entirely different scale of value.
The benchmark colour — "muzo green", named after the Colombian Muzo mine — is a warm, slightly bluish green with an inner luminosity that no treated emerald can match. A certificate confirming the complete absence of treatment (no oil) can multiply the value of an emerald by three to five times compared with a treated stone of the same colour.
Houses such as Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels and Bulgari have built iconic pieces around the emerald. Cartier's Tutti Frutti collection, with its Indian emeralds, helped enshrine this stone in the history of world high jewellery. At Bonnot Paris, we select our emeralds directly in Jaipur, the global hub of the green gem trade.
Beyond the classic 4Cs, several factors specifically determine the market value of a coloured precious stone. Here they are, in order of importance.
Value factor no. 1
Burma for ruby, Kashmir for sapphire, Colombia for emerald: a certified origin can multiply the value of a stone by two to ten times.
Untreated = absolute premium
A certified untreated stone is consistently worth far more than a similar treated one. Heating for sapphire and ruby, oiling for emerald, are common practices but reduce value.
70% of value
The benchmark hue (pigeon blood, muzo green, cornflower blue) justifies the premium price. A slight deviation from the ideal colour can halve or even reduce the value threefold.
GRS · GIA · ALGT
A certificate from a leading laboratory confirms origin and treatments. Without a recognised certificate, a top-tier stone loses a large part of its market value and liquidity.
Exponential value
Value does not increase linearly with weight — it is exponential. A 5-carat ruby is not worth five times a 1-carat ruby: it can be worth twenty to fifty times more.
History & collections
Having belonged to a great collection or a prestigious jewellery house adds further value. Stones with a documented history consistently sell above estimate.
Exceptional-quality precious stones have historically weathered economic downturns with resilience. Unlike financial assets, a fine certified gemstone is tangible, portable and universally recognised. It represents a discreet store of value that some investors choose to incorporate into their estate.
Untreated Burmese rubies, Kashmir sapphires and untreated Colombian emeralds are the three categories that have performed most strongly over the past twenty years. Their growing scarcity — the historic deposits being exhausted or close to it — provides structural long-term support to their value.
At Bonnot Paris, we guide clients who wish to combine beauty with lasting value in the choice of their bespoke jewel. Our direct sourcing in India, Sri Lanka and Thailand allows us to identify stones of high potential well before they reach the European market.
For a purchase that combines pleasure with investment, favour a certified precious stone with a fine natural colour, ideally untreated or minimally treated, and with a documented origin. It is the combination of these criteria — not carat weight alone — that will determine the future value of your stone. Book an appointment for personalised guidance.
The ruby is regularly the most expensive precious stone per carat. An untreated Burmese ruby of exceptional "pigeon blood" colour can exceed one million euros per carat at auction. Certain extraordinary pink or blue diamonds reach similar records, but at an even more extreme degree of rarity.
The exceptional value of the ruby lies in its absolute rarity: large untreated "pigeon blood" rubies from Burma are among the rarest gemstones on earth. Its hardness (9 on the Mohs scale), its natural fluorescence and its millennia-long history make it the precious stone most coveted by the great jewellery houses.
Not necessarily. While the white diamond is the most popular engagement stone, Burmese rubies, Kashmir sapphires and untreated Colombian emeralds often surpass the white diamond in value per carat. That said, extraordinary pink or blue diamonds rank among the most expensive stones ever sold at auction.
The value of a precious stone rests on the combination of the 4Cs (colour, clarity, cut, carat), its certified geographic origin, and the absence or presence of treatments. Only a gemmological certificate issued by a recognised laboratory (GIA, GRS, ALGT) can attest to these characteristics. At Bonnot Paris, all our stones are certified — book an appointment to find out more.
Partagez ce post
Découvrez d'autres articles qui peuvent vous intéresser pour approfondir votre passion pour la joaillerie !
View all
